New research by a multidisciplinary collaboration between Asthma UK Centre for Applied Research (AUKCAR): Queen Mary and Edinburgh, eHealth Interdisciplinary Group: Edinburgh, University of Nottingham, University of Cambridge, and the charity Asthma UK, published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, looks at the characteristics of superusers who are actively engaged in the Asthma UK online community and Facebook group to help health care professionals better understand the role they play in supporting the management of long-term conditions.
The Role of the Superuser
Online health communities help people to self-manage certain aspects of their long-term conditions better through harnessing the support and knowledge held by other users in the network. They are mostly run on a voluntary basis by their users. Superusers (the 1% of highly active users) play a central role in these communities as a result of the characteristics of their online activity and their constant engagement.
Online health communities offer high potential for cost-effectiveness in helping to manage long-term conditions. Therefore, understanding the mechanisms of online health communities’ effectiveness, how they are organized, and how they evolve over time is key. Previous work by the researchers looking at the Asthma UK online community has shown the presence of 20-30 superusers that are active on a weekly basis among 3345 users. Removal of these superusers would make the network collapse into isolated nonconnected groups. Thus, superusers are responsible for holding the communities together.
Without superusers there would be no effective spread of information and support within the community. However, up until now, there has been little research into the characteristics of superusers. This study explores who they are, their motivations behind their engagement, the difficulties they face, and what role they wish for health care professionals to play in health social media.
Highly Motivated, Altruistic, and Mostly Female Individuals
The researchers found that superusers in the Asthma UK online community and Facebook group are patients and mothers of children with asthma from a wide age range. They have a strong intrinsic motivation behind their engagement, and their behavior is self-endorsed, reflecting autonomy. Curiosity about asthma and its medical treatment was a main reason for engaging with the community, and engagement is often determined by availability of spare time when they were off work due to asthma exacerbations or retired. Their engagement increased over time as participants furthered their familiarity with the online health community, their interest in community members, and their knowledge of asthma and its self-management.
Extrinsic motivation such as financial rewards was not relevant, as their reward came from helping and interacting with others. However, superusers do experience moral pressure to monitor health social media, answer any requests of help, rectify any inappropriate advice (misunderstandings about asthma and its treatment such as “miracle cures” or dangerous ideas), or address users who are not seeking medical help when appropriate. These are things that superusers found difficult and stressful to deal with at times. Despite this, most health care professionals are not aware of their patients’ engagement with health social media.
Reassuringly, superusers also show judgement about the complexity of coping with the illness and the limits of their advice, knowing when to defer to health care providers for appropriate medical advice and intervention.
Olivia Fulton, coauthor of the paper and superuser of a large patient advocate network via WEGO Health, said, “I think no matter the condition, superuser traits are the same; I don’t think it’s unique for certain conditions like asthma. Superusers tend to have long-lived experience of the condition and seek out the most up-to-date information so they know where to direct people should the need arise. Many have been healthcare or allied healthcare professionals but have had to stop work due to ill health and therefore feel that by supporting an online forum, they are still doing something purposeful.
“Superusers are an underutilized ally because often we will see questions from someone newly diagnosed who has felt too embarrassed to ask their GP or nurse, but feel a forum is a faceless platform where they can ask these questions. Although, I am not sure how healthcare professionals would be able to identify superusers among their patients, as I never considered myself as one before it was pointed out to me.”
This study shines a light on a particular group of superusers active in the Asthma UK online community and Facebook group. Further research should also examine whether superuser traits are shared among highly connected individuals in other health social media such as Twitter. Given the effectiveness in helping people to self-manage their conditions, the study poses the question on whether superusers should be formally recognized as allies of the health care workforce.
Lead author Dr Anna De Simoni said, “As a GP, I have become more inquisitive with my patients about any potential engagement with health social media and support they may need. I believe clinicians can have an important role in conveying norms and values for engaging safely and positively in health social media. During the COVID-19 lockdown, patients with asthma have likely been relying even more on peer support from superusers. Superusers’ activity, at the same time, generates the ‘hardware of online connections’ enabling the crowdsourcing of information and support.”
• Find out more about Asthma UK Centre for Applied Research
• Find out more about Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry, Queen Mary University of London
• Looking inside online health communities for people with chronic diseases: what holds them up? – July 12, 2018
Anna De Simoni, Anjali T Shah, Olivia Fulton, Jasmine Parkinson, Aziz Sheikh, Pietro Panzarasa, Claudia Pagliari, Neil S Coulson, Chris J Griffiths
Superusers’ Engagement in Asthma Online Communities: Asynchronous Web-Based Interview Study
J Med Internet Res 2020;22(6)e18185